Search:

lets fight to make America the great country it once was
I love America

A blog about Politics, Food & Eating, and Animals.
About gube


Member Since:
August 26, 2007
Last Signed In:
November 21, 2008
Profile Views:
2567
Blog Views:
28843
View Profile
Send a Message
Send To A Friend
Sign Guestbook
Add as a Friend

Previous Posts
gube is having gastric bypass next tuesday
Two fight at Jacobsen middle school
Priest: No communion for Obama supporters
College Health raided by the DA..........
The right wing killing machine is broke
NBC/WSJ poll: Obama holds significant lead
Back in the U.S., and back in trouble
Blvd of Discrimination
Praying for Election Day miracles
'I Would Make A Bad President,' Obama Says In Huge Campaign Blunder
Archives
August 07
September 07
October 07
November 07
December 07
January 08
February 08
March 08
April 08
May 08
June 08
July 08
August 08
September 08
October 08
November 08

Hi my name is gube.......I hate illegal aliens..............I love Americans..........

Subscribe!
RSS 2.0 feed RSS 2.0
Add to My Yahoo
Add to My Google
Add to Bloglines
Add to My AOL
gube - > lets fight to make America the great country it once was -> what dose pro life realy mean
what dose pro life realy mean

Can someone please explain to me why it is ok to execute a murderer on death row but it's not ok to kill a unborn baby.  Shouldn't pro life mean pro life ?..I support the women decision. I do not believe that a man should tell a female what she can do and what she can't do with her body. And I do not believe in the death penalty. We as a society say that killing is wrong , And then what do we do. We kill. How many pro life people believe in the death penalty. Whats the difference in killing a unborn baby or a person convicted of murder. 

Posted in these Groups:
Topics:
posted by gube on Saturday, September 22, 2007 at 04:42 PM
Report a Violation
Viewed 266 times
29 comments from 13 users

1 2

posted by jer72 on Sep 26, 2007 at 06:51 AM
Here is my two cents.

First the baby is not a parasite, it is a baby. It has human DNA that come from both  parents which makes it a fetus.

Fetus- (used chiefly of viviparous mammals) the young of an animal in the womb or egg, esp. in the later stages of development when the body structures are in the recognizable form of its kind, in humans after the end of the second month of gestation.

Now here is my believe as to why I believe in the death penalty and not abortion.

First the baby is innocent and up to this point and been able to do nothing to hurt anyone or anything. Yes I know that child birth hurts, but that is different than endangering the woman's life.

Second the murderer has already proven himself to kill. He has been born and chose to kill others for what ever reason he had.
Now here is an idea most I don't  see or realize. If a man kills a pregnant woman regardless if she knew , wanted it, or etc... The man will be charged with two murders. It does not matter if the woman was on her way to the clinic for an abortion, the man is arrested for two murders. It also does not matter if the woman is in the first or last trimester, it is still two murders.

So now if we believe the fetus is a parasite, isn't it only one murder? If abortion is legal up to a certain point, then it shouldn't be murder until the same point also. So is abortion murder or is it the removal of a parasite?
posted by madkow2747 on Sep 23, 2007 at 11:01 AM
There is no contradiction.  There is no hypocrisy.  It isn't a matter of respecting life, it's a matter of giving people what they deserve.  An innocent child deserves to live because the mother has a responsibility to protect it.  A very evil person (IMO) deserves to die when they have done society immeasurable harm be taking the life of another (or others).  It is not the judge, it is not the prosecutor, it is not the prison system that is putting him/her to death.  It is the jury of his/her peers that sentenced him/her.  It is "the people" versus this person, which represents all of us.  And why is it not within the right of our society to lawfully punish, even if it means eliminating a terrible threat to the life of others.  Is that not respectful to life as well?  And what of the life of the victims?  And the potential future victims?  Nobody even considers them in this debate.

And peacetoyou, I couldn't agree more!  The best way to keep abortion down is education!!!  Though, I wonder how many people that are all for abortions really know how abortions are performed and all the legal time frames.  It's fascinating to learn and had a huge impact on my current stance.
posted by medicone on Sep 23, 2007 at 10:01 AM

"Look at Europe, there popluation is declining due to abortions and birth control, there are more people dying than being born."

And this is a bad thing?  If this was world wide for a few decades, the world would be a better place!  There are to many people on this plant as it is now.

posted by peacetoyou on Sep 23, 2007 at 08:45 AM

What I feel most  people need to understand is that being “pro-choice” does not mean you are pro-abortion. How many women wake up one day and say, “Hmmm, I’ll go out and get pregnant so I can experience the joy of an abortion!”? None is my guess.   I am pro-family, pro-child and pro-choice.

Being “pro-choice” is saying you have the right to have and keep your baby, have and give your baby up for adoption or a woman may choose to terminate the pregnancy safely.  The best way to keep abortion numbers down is EDUCATION. Less unintended pregnancies means less abortions.

On the death penalty, I go back and forth, I readily admit to being a 'wall sitter' on this one.

In peace,

Annette

 

posted by rm6 on Sep 22, 2007 at 10:27 PM

Wow Raiderfan (I too am a fan of the Raiders, too bad they suck yet again this year)...I guess that reference went way over your head, I did, after all, take AP Biology in high school, where we outlined virtually the entire book, and I passed the AP Bio exam with a 5 (the highest score possible), so I guess I don't know anything about biology at all. Sorry about the sarcasm, but it ticks me off when people claim that I or someone else lacks knowledge, but provides no evidence to back up that claim.

Regardless of the negative connotations, a parasite is an organism that lives on or in another organism, from which it obtains nutrients, which I believe is exactly what the fetus does until it exits the mother's body.

Madkow, that "what if" question was posed as a response to a comment that has since been deleted, you're right it doesn't make much sense now that that comment is gone.

posted by countygirl on Sep 22, 2007 at 10:14 PM

I have to admit that it is a lot easier to feel sorry for an unborn child that is totally innocent and defenseless with no one to fight for them(heck even the murders have someone to plead their case) than some murderer that has senselessly taken lives. Especially those that commit crimes against children. While I don't think we should be killing people( I don't think it's up to us to take life) I still fight with my initial reaction of "Kill them, kill them all" after hearing about some pervert that has committed crimes against our children!

Oh, and I do not believe in abortion. As a matter of fact I'll be at the fair this Mon. working in my PRO-LIFE booth. Feel free to come by and say "hi" if you're there!

posted by madkow2747 on Sep 22, 2007 at 09:50 PM
Okay, I have to add this.  rm6- abortions for medical reasons are practically always understandable (except maybe by a few religious nuts).  There are not many people that would debate that.  And if you commit justifiable homicide, there is no way you are going to be given the death penalty.  You probably wouldn't even get prosecuted for murder.  Not very good points.

Raiderfan- I believe rm6 is just talking about a theory by David Haig, a biologist, who proposed that a fetus acts in a similar fashion as a parasite to a mother's body (i.e. fighting for limited resources).  And there is evidence that the mother's body actually resists pregnancy (silly IMO).  One part of the theory is the fact that the vagina is acidic (though it's mainly to fight infection) and the cowpers gland (in the male reproductive system) has to put out a basic secretion (pre-cum) in order to neutralize the environment and make it suitable for the survival of sperm.  A woman's body has many defenses though and the male system is tailor designed to defeat these defenses to ensure reproduction.

An interesting article on Haig's theory:  http://www.nytimes.com/2006...
posted by raiderfan on Sep 22, 2007 at 09:15 PM
rm6- A child is a parasite until they are born? Are you kidding me? Wow for being valedictorian that is pretty scary. Then you sure didn't learn to much in school. An unborn child is called a fetus not a parasite!!!
posted by madkow2747 on Sep 22, 2007 at 07:47 PM
I'm pro-life (to use the typical label) and pro-death penalty.  I'm not interested in criminalizing abortion, but I think it is morally wrong.  I am a mother, so I admit that I look at it through a mother's eyes.  When I found out that I was pregnant, my child became my main responsibility.  I was obligated to care for my body in order to nurture the life of another who was dependent on me.  So you see the major point (or flaw) in my argument: I saw my child as a child from the moment I knew he existed (which I knew even before I tested for pregnancy). 

I'm pro-death penalty for a somewhat selfish reason, really.  I like vengeance when someone (IMO) "deserves" it.  If someone, say, kills a child, brutally, violently, horribly, then I say kill them back :)  (perhaps an inappropriate usage of the smiley, hehe)  I certainly believe that the proof has to be incontrovertible; otherwise let them exhaust their appeals and rot in prison.  I know it's not a crime deterrent.  I know it's more expensive to put someone to death than keep them in prison for life.  But I think it's within the rights of the people to execute a person who is evil enough to commit the most evil crimes.

All life is precious, but our decisions make us into the people we are.  Unborn babies have not made decisions- they are innocent.  Murderers have taken the lives of others- they have no innocence or any claim to their own lives.  Just my two cents...
posted by Colitas on Sep 22, 2007 at 07:40 PM
You can't kill something that is not alive.  So yes there is a difference from killing the born and killing the unborn.   The problem bigdog is they do get reading materials, tv, etc.  If all they could do is eat, crap and look at the walls, my views might change.
posted by bigdog on Sep 22, 2007 at 07:13 PM

Being a man i find it hard to tell a girl what or what she can't do with her body. I don't like abortion but I also don't like telling a girl that she can not have a abortion, or that she has to have one. To me its a girl topic. and I leave it at that.

As far as the death penalty I'm not for it. Idon't think it is used fairly. and it is not a deterrent. most death row inmates are poor. and many had  bad lawyers.  Other then Scott Peterson name some other well off murderers that got the chair. Lock them in their cells 23 hours a day. take away the tv's.let them spend the rest of their lifes sitting in that little cell thinking about what they did. Killing them is giving them a out. Once there dead there dead. Keep them alive,fed them and that's it.Could you imagine living the rest of your life in 9 by 6 cell with no tv or reading materials. just you and yourself to talk to.

posted by Colitas on Sep 22, 2007 at 06:36 PM
I too believe in pro-choice and the death penalty.  I just wish if a person has been found guilty and punished to death, and have the right to appeal, there should be a time limit.  There case should be looked over for any gross negligence and if found a valid conviction, they should up hold that within a year.  I know personally the problems of having a death row for years and years.  And of course some of the laws on the books need to be changed.  Sometimes your hands are tied in what to do.  I believe murder constitutes the death penalty.  Not so much homicide.  Again, it depends on the states definitions and so forth. 
posted by rm6 on Sep 22, 2007 at 05:57 PM

I think it's ironic that there are pro-life/pro-death penalty people out there...isn't that kind of hypocritical, like when an anti-abortionist blows up a clinic?

An unborn baby isn't an innocent child, it is a parasite until it is born.

We may say that killing is wrong and that human lives are precious, but that certainly isn't what we practice. When I see mass murder (aka war) over beliefs or money or whatever and people dying for whatever their government tells them to, I see that what we REALLY mean is that human lives are expendable in nearly all circumstances.

 

posted by gube on Sep 22, 2007 at 05:53 PM
anonymous are you a pro lifer and if you are do you believe in the death penalty ? ..........  I don't support abortion, I support the women's right to chose...............  how can you say that you  are pro life and support the death penalty ....
1 2

  (You need to be signed in to leave a comment)