Search:

Serenity
Anything and everything.
About rm6


Gender:
male
Date of Birth:
May 20, 1988
Member Since:
March 27, 2007
Last Signed In:
December 01, 2008
Profile Views:
604
Blog Views:
1287
View Profile
Send a Message
Send To A Friend
Sign Guestbook
Add as a Friend

Previous Posts
Something that really bugs me
my response to heath's "innocence" article, in case my comment is deleted
haha you're a funny man
WalMart
Archives
July 07
August 07
September 07
October 07
November 07
December 07
January 08
February 08
March 08
April 08
May 08
June 08
July 08
August 08
September 08
October 08
November 08
December 08
Subscribe!
RSS 2.0 feed RSS 2.0
Add to My Yahoo
Add to My Google
Add to Bloglines
Add to My AOL
rm6 - > Serenity -> my response to heath's "innocence" article, in case my comment is deleted
my response to heath's "innocence" article, in case my comment is deleted

Seriously, who cares? I'm sure all the "innocent" children could care less what the sexuality of Dumbledore is as IT IS NOT RELEVANT TO THE STORY LINE, only adults with personal agendas make a big deal about this kind of stuff. I think you're using the "innocence of children should not be betrayed" argument as a front to express your own misgivings about homosexuality ("There is good cause for those of us believing Rowling for whatever reason chose such a self-destructive thing as pronouncing Dumbledore a homosexual succumbing to some inner demon, a moment of temporary insanity if you will."). The innocence isn't being betrayed, no where in the books does she even imply that he is gay. Why does it even matter to anyone that a fictional character is gay? Don't we have better things to think (or worry?) about?

Just because your Ph.D qualifies you to say something doesn't mean that your "professional opinion" is the end all of the discussion. The targeted population will always be entertained by the books because of the great story that is told, that is, unless people like you ruin it by lambasting the author for what she said after the series was finished when it doesn't even have any relevance to the story.

 

Posted in these Groups:
Topics:
posted by rm6 on Saturday, November 3, 2007 at 11:40 PM
Report a Violation
Viewed 184 times
20 comments from 9 users

1 2

posted by awsmom8 on Nov 6, 2007 at 10:18 AM
Thanks Trouble!  I just knew you would set us straight!!!!!  I had no doubt about it!!!! ; )
posted by trouble on Nov 6, 2007 at 09:51 AM
urge hell i'll show you a urge. Yo awsmom8 i aint no flammer i'm prison gay, there is a differance. get it right or i'll be seeing you....got it. YO big pooch you damn right your not going to call me a flammer to my face cause if you did i would add you to my you can kiss my azz club and kix your azz
posted by bigdog on Nov 6, 2007 at 09:08 AM

well Trouble is a little mix up but i wouldn't call him a flamer......at least i wouldn't call him one to his face.

posted by bigdog on Nov 6, 2007 at 08:06 AM
oilfeildtrash sorry dude but i personally don't know any man that went to prison as a straight guy and came out as a flammer.....................
posted by rm6 on Nov 6, 2007 at 07:51 AM
heh heh, good point about the homocide thing...
posted by Joty on Nov 6, 2007 at 07:50 AM

Yes, rm6, I was referring to learned behavior regarding sexuality. I don't think I agree that sexuality comes down to being just an urge either. Addictions are urges. I believe each human is born with a sexual predilection firmly in place.

Homicide is not a behavior either. Again, an urge that a lot of us might think about but don't act on.

And Ben, my little female Chihuahua will hump anything...LOL!!!

posted by rm6 on Nov 5, 2007 at 09:39 PM
They have pills to fix simple chemical imbalances that presumably cause things like depression, however trying to alter an instinct and that is what sexual identity is, is way beyond the technologies of today.
posted by oilfieldtrash72 on Nov 5, 2007 at 08:54 PM

You make valid points rm6. I agree with you but I would think that if it's a chemical composition issue, they'd have a pill for that. Maybe they do. hmmm time to do some research.

Thanks.

 

posted by rm6 on Nov 5, 2007 at 08:12 PM

I think Joty means that she doesn't buy into the idea that homosexuality is a learned behavior.

Being male and being white aren't behaviors, but homosexuality isn't either, it is a feeling, an urge. It only becomes a behavior if you act on that urge.

I definitely think that some people are born more inclined to be homocidal, but it's not as simple as that. One might be born with a personality disorder which makes them more inclined to kill.

When it comes down to it, it's the levels of chemicals in our brains that dictate our behavior, so unless you can consicously alter those levels, I don't see any way for our feelings, urges, or the likelyhood of us acting on those urges to be entirely a consequence of conscious choice. Seeing that homo and heterosexuality are feelings or urges, I don't think that being gay is totally a matter of wanting to be that way.

posted by oilfieldtrash72 on Nov 5, 2007 at 07:59 PM

Homosexuality occurs in wild animals? Wow, ya learn somethin new everyday. oO(I gotta watch more Animal Planet).

Joty, I can't define normal. That's why I put it in "quotes" just as you quoted "learned behavior". Now maybe I'm wrong but being male and being white aren't behaviors. I do agree that I was "born straight". But I must ask, how can you not believe in learned behavior? Isn't that one of parents' main roles as parents? To teach their children how to behave in pulic, in school, in church, at family functions, etc? Perhaps "learned sexual preference" or "learned sexual orientation" are better terms. Out of curiosity, do you think that murderers are born murderers? Either way, isn't is saying the same thing?

I can't believe I'm actually enjoying the conversation about this topic.  Enquiring minds I guess.   :)

posted by Joty on Nov 5, 2007 at 06:30 PM

First Oilfield, define normal...

I don't buy into the "learned behavior". Did you choose to be born male? Did you choose to be white? Did you choose to be straight? Nope, you were born that way.

People who deny their sexuality do it out of fear of societal rejection and too many times familial rejection. What person would choose to have to listen to people just as jim (go read his blog...he's f**in nuts). Something else you might want to think about. Maybe it's just Mother Nature's way of population control. What if everyone on earth were breeders? Oy!

Why can't people just live and let live?

posted by oilfieldtrash72 on Nov 5, 2007 at 09:57 AM
I get so confused on this subject. For every study that “proves” that it’s a genetic makeup issue, there is a study that “proves” that it’s a learned behavior or it’s due to some traumatic experience in a person’s life. So basically you can’t believe anything anyone else says. You can’t fault someone for being born that way. But are they born that way? I mean, from all the talk shows I’ve seen on the subject, I would have to say yes. The majority of the homosexuals on talk shows say that they didn’t want to be gay, they just are. I truly believe that not all homosexuals had a poor childhood or experienced some traumatic event that “caused” them to be that way. Sure, it could be some big conspiracy by Hollywood to “make it ok” or desensitize the general public to homosexuality. Then again, I have personally spoke to some gay people who have said the same thing. They grew up wishing they were “normal”. They wished that they were not gay. That only leads me to believe that they are truly born that way. How many stories have you heard about a husband leaving his wife for another man or vice versa? Doesn’t that show that they were denying their true sexuality?   On the other hand, how many stories have you heard about a completely straight guy going to prison and coming out a total flamer and not wanting to have anything to do with women? Or what about the guy that experiments with threesomes and/or orgies then ends up preferring men? Was he gay or bi all along and didn’t know it or did he just learn to like it? Honestly I think it can also be a learned behavior.   I have two cousins that are gay. One has been with women before but never had a girlfriend that I could remember. The other was married and has two children. I love them very much and I just tell them “hey, whatever blows your skirt up, but I don’t want to see it.”   All I really know is it’s just too much for my feeble little brain to handle :)
posted by Joty on Nov 5, 2007 at 08:54 AM
lol...yep. Speaking of jim, HE would be perfect for Jerry Springer!!!!
posted by olivia on Nov 4, 2007 at 06:56 PM
I know what you mean Joty, I have read some of Sam's blogs.  They are so long. But when the topic is interesting I enjoy reading them.  Then Bam out of nowhere, I read this homosexual deviant comment.  My first thought was .... JIM.
posted by Joty on Nov 4, 2007 at 10:16 AM

I was in my twenties when I realized gay people are just like you and me. When I think back on all the hateful things my mother (again, because of how she was raised) would say and I would parrot her, it must have been like knives in my brother's heart. He knew from the age of three that he was "different". We hurt him through ignorance, but thankfully, most of my family have taken the time to listen and learn. And you know what's funny? Most people deal with gay people on a day-to-day basis and don't even realize it, lol. And I don't think there is a family that exists that doesn't have at least one gay relative. In my large family, there are several.

Madkow, something tells me Sam is not real current on these issues. He seems to be so intelligent his attitude kinda caught me off guard.

1 2

  (You need to be signed in to leave a comment)