A project featuring the construction of up to 320 new wind turbines moved another step closer to reality last Thursday.
The county planning commission voted 5-0 on Nov. 12 to recommend to the county board of supervisors to approve zone changes that would allow for the placement of the Alta-Oak Creek Mojave Project in East Kern.
Project supporters and opponents both spoke during the public meeting Thursday. In the end, commission members believed the plan's positives outweighed any problems brought forth by residents, consisting almost exclusively of residents from Old West Ranch near Tehachapi.
“This is what's needed, this is what's coming,” commission Chairman Ronald Sprague said. “I'm in support of the project.”
Fellow commission members Peter Belluomini, Jeff Flores, Chris Babcock and Leticia Perez voted with Sprague to approve the recommendation brought forth by staff.
The decision came following dissention by several East Kern residents who said they weren't against wind energy, but were simply opposed to large wind turbines near their property.
Old West Ranch resident Terry Beckett told the commission she was concerned the turbines could throw ice from their blades during colder months.
“Who is going to keep my children safe?” she asked.
Brent Scheibel echoed Beckett's concerns, saying he did not think turbines were being built far enough from homes to ensure the safety of Old West Ranch residents.
Randy Hoyle, representing Terra-Gen, the company overseeing the project, said turbines would slow down and stop if they became icy.
Hoyle said ice being thrown from turbine blades “is of little danger.”
Glenn Mueller, a property owner in the Old West Ranch area since 1964, said he wished for two 40-acre parcels consisting of three turbines not to be approved.
Hoyle said Terra-Gen would “take a look at” the idea of removing those two parcels.
On Oct. 22, Alta Wind removed “Subarea 3” - which was to encompass as many as 13 turbines - from the project's plans after it was revealed that airspace around Tehachapi's Mountain Valley Airport would be encroached upon.
With that subarea removed, the project is now scheduled to be built on 9,120 acres, 2,720 of which would be rezoned, commission staff said.
Project supporters also spoke before the commission.
Hoyle said the project would displace two million tons of carbon dioxide per year, add 200 construction jobs and 50 permanent jobs and contribute $30.4 million to the area.
Terra-Gen currently employs 30 full time staff members in the Tehachapi area, Hoyle said.
Hoyle called the project a “historic opportunity,” in the world of alternative energy.
“We want to meet every goal we possibly can,” said Linda Parker, executive director of the Kern Wind Energy Association.
Commission member Chris Babcock said Old West Ranch residents' complaints probably stemmed from “first-generation” wind turbines, which are louder and less efficient.
“I am, for one, in support of this project,” he said.
Commission member Peter Belluomini said he understood the concerns of those speaking against portions of the project.
“Some people think alternative energy is the bee's knees, and some don't,” he said.
Added Belluomini, “Some of them are caught in a hard spot. Nothing is ever perfect.”
Commission staff recommended that Terra-Gen fund a full-time sheep monitor to observe sheep grazing in fields near the project. Staff made the recommendation hoping to deter California condors from flying too close to the wind turbines as they flew in toward possibly deceased sheep.
Comments
The article fails to disclose the permanent impacts that wind turbines will have on the health of the surrounding habitats and overall quality of the local environment, going forward, if approved by the Board of Supervisors. Today, the ecosystem in the community of Old West Ranch is in the hands of truly, green-living self-sustaining residents, with alternative energy and no outside sources of electricity or utilities. The lands are close to pristine and remain so under the stewardship of the residents. Flocks of turkey vultures fly above an enchanted forest of very old pines and oaks. The endangered California condor was also sighted in the area. A tour of the area convinced me that Old West Ranch and the retention of other sanctuaries must be protected from destruction, no exceptions. If windmills can be installed with zero impact on the environment, fine. Anything less is unacceptable.
The mitigating away of the federal protection of the California condors is solely comprised on phasing out the sheep grazing near the turbines, where a sheep could possibly die and go unnoticed. The theory is that the condor flies down for a meal on carrion and is at risk of being wacked. So, take away the sheep and the problem goes away. Wrong. The scientists that brought these magnificent birds back from extinction worked hard to secure their continued survival. Why haven’t they been consulted and active participants in the decision making and mitigation process? Instead, politicians, hungry for tax and other revenues, continue the pattern of keeping a blind eye to the need to preserve the biodiversity of the ecosystems and resources that give us life and secures our basic needs for food, water and shelter. The unanimous decision lacks the use of sound judgment knowing the collateral disturbance and harassment to the wildlife, nesting areas, food and water sources, migratory paths, inadequate territories and collapse that will take place. It is difficult to imagine that the ecosystem will stay intact for long with the level of disturbance that the installation, maintenance and operation of the turbines will produce. Roads, noises, vibrations, loss of terrain and inadequate territory, habitat fragmentation are not conducive to a healthy ecosystem.
It is NO LONGER ACCEPTABLE to be forced to choose between green energy, economy, jobs, growth or whatever the Campbell soup crisis of the day happens to be OR the environment.
During the energy committee hearings in Congress in late October, it was stated by Sen. Kerry that scientists give a 10 year window before we really begin to experience the effects of climate change.
Map of planned wind farm (SW The.-Willow Springs/Highline):
http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&source=hp&q=tehachapi%2C%20ca&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wl
Link about turbine noise:
http://acousticecology.org/srwind.html
Link to: Kern Planning Commission meeting 11/12/09:
http://kern.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=9&clip_id=1246
Wind energy impacts on habitats:http://www.windaction.org/faqs/18574
Effects on Wildlife:
http://www.vawind.org/Assets/Docs/Key%20Issues%2001-06-06.pdf
It’s time for man to put up a permanent fence that physically separates us from the rest of wildlife and ecosystems. We have no understanding of what global warming really means to the future survival of life on earth. It will be more productive to redirect our attention to survival strategies to preserve the integrity of our life support systems rather than continue to engage in the distraction of yet another economic bubble called green energy. Let’s not throw the baby away with the bath water.
The bigger picture is the rezoning of open land in the Mojave Desert to wind, industrial, commercial and residential development that is found within the Kern County General Plan, approved in 2007. The Mojave Desert is the smallest of 4 contiguous desert areas in the U.S. and Mexico. Scientists that live and breathe global warming and have studied, observed, reported and peer reviewed by the scientific community, that ecosystems are collapsing rapidly because of development, chemicals, dumping into streams that poison those complex habitats and fossil fuel CO2 emissions. If allowed, this will result in more extinctions, more decentralization, urban sprawl and dependence on gasoline, more loss of fertile land and top soil that cannot be replaced in a lifetime, loss of water and food security, privatization of our resources that will continue to be doled out to us at a high cost. Basically, this amounts to banging a few morenails on the lids of our coffins. Link:
http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.mbgnet.net/sets/desert/desert.gif&imgrefurl=http://www.mbgnet.net/sets/desert/ofworld.htm&h=292&w=298&sz=6&tbnid=XWUB-ObX_hNFWM:&tbnh=114&tbnw=116&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dnorth%2Bamerican%2Bdeserts&hl=en&usg=__jBGWLpmaU56Vl7s-6PLOeaH6oak=&ei=VwIHS6aZF4GwtAP5sK3sDA&sa=X&oi=image_result&resnum=6&ct=image&ved=0CBcQ9QEwBQ