If you were swimming and fishing in the Kern River back in the 40s you might have heard someone say, “The Kern River mile for mile is the most dangerous river in the world for loss of lives.” Even as a kid I thought this farfetched, something fabulous or extravagant some of the grownups would say as a warning like; “Be careful with that BB gun; you can put your eye out.” And while I never actually knew a kid that had stuck the barrel of his BB gun up to his eye and pulled the trigger, such things actually happened through carelessness on some rare occasions; which only proved to me as a boy that occasionally some kids could be as stupid as some adults.
However, when I saw the very first warning sign about the Kern River posted at the mouth of the canyon years ago my first reaction was resentment. I resented some nanny government functionary stating the patently obvious fact that you could actually drown in the river! Hey! Here were the “grownups” telling me once more I could put my eye out with my BB gun! But really, I thought at the time, have people actually become so stupid they don’t know a plunge into boulder-strewn, white water rapids is a dangerous thing to do?
Over the years we have become accustomed, in many cases callous to the many ways government attempts to control our lives to the extent we now live in an America where anyone can be sued for any reason, an America where lawyers and judges rule our lives and in which Big Brother will step in and tell us “what is best for our own good,” but in the end no one from the President on down is expected to accept personal responsibility for anything.
We need warning labels in many instances, and that skull and crossbones logo on some medicines I recall from childhood, and still used today, were necessary. And kids need all the adult supervision possible at all times. As a child I needed someone to point out what that skull and crossbones on a label meant. But a child can, and too often does, drown in a pail of water because of the lack of adult supervision. Adults need caution labels on buckets warning them this can happen? There needs to be caution labels on bathtubs warning children can drown in them?
Perhaps the warning signs about the Kern River are a good thing. But when I was teaching shop classes, during safety instruction I would tell my pupils “You can make a machine foolproof; but you cannot make it fool proof.” Over the years I collected an archive of stories about fools that make the point.
From childhood I have been engaged in “risk behavior;” guns, motorcycles, fast cars and airplanes; all of which do not suffer fools, and will certainly kill fools. When I started flying in the 50s a fellow had a J3-Cub at the Torrance airport with “armstrong starter.” I didn’t need my buddy to tell me that prop could kill you if you didn’t watch yourself. There was no warning label on that prop and there is a very good reason the guy in the plane shouts “Contact!” when he is ready for you to pull that prop through to start the engine. What I didn’t expect was when we took off he decided to teach me how to put the bird in an intentional spin so I could learn how to recover. This is no longer allowed because of the danger of such a maneuver. I recall the placard prominently displayed on a WWII AT-6 at Minter Field that read: Do Not Put This Aircraft In An Intentional Spin!
So, there is a proper time and place for warning signs and labels. Perhaps the Kern River needs such signs. But the resentment remains that there are such people Big Brother needs to care for because they are fools. My resentment stems from there seeming to be no want of fools that need to be told they can actually drown in the Kern River. Worse; the less personal responsibility and personal accountability we see in our government the more the fools seem to outnumber those with just plain common sense. And the signs and labels just keep multiplying, but they will never prevent anyone from being a damned fool, they will never make the “Killer Kern” fool proof.
Comments
Rather than argue I will just say I completely disagree with your position.
As for not being able to instruct the instructor I refuse to believe simply because you have taught in the past you are an "expert" in the subject. I too have taught and I offer there are fantastic teachers and there are teachers who are not worth the powder to blow them to Hell. Merely having "been there-done that" doesn't mean you cannot continue the learning process.
I will concede my "telepathy" remark was off the mark. However it was used to show the flawed logic in expecting someone to somehow have knowledge when there has been no instruction. See the paradox?
To expect someone who is not from the Kern County area to magically have knowledge of the dangers inherent in swimming in the Kern River is akin to a geometry teacher having a final exam consisting of world geography. It is an unreasonable expectation. "Common Knowledge" is only common if everyone involved has the information.
These signs are not (repeat NOT) for the 6-pac drinking Oildale 25 year old. As resident of Bakersfield or Kern County he (the 25 year old Oildallian) WOULD know the dangers. Rather it is specifically for those visiting Kern County who have never heard of the Kern River. To infer having knowledge of the dangers of the Kern River is a matter of personal responsibility (when you have never even heard of the Kern River) is a stretch of the imagination and a huge leap.
As you said, you have your opinion, I mine.
Sam:
To me these signs are about education not personal accountability. If you read the sign THEN go in the river anyway, then it would, in fact, be about personal accountability.
Like the skull & crossbones on the 1950's bottle of iodine, these signs are to warn out of town visitors the waters of the Kern are not cool and inviting- they are dangerous!
Pray tell, how can an out of town visitor know of the danger if we residents don't tell them?
Therein lies the paradox.
We soundly criticize parents for letting their kids swim in the dangerous waters of the Kern River yet how can this same father know of the danger to his family?
Telepathy?
It doesn't work that way. If you know the danger and fail to communicate it to the visitor, you are aiding and abetting the deaths. It's not nannyism, its education and there is a difference.
The philosophy you espouse regarding signs, safety (when it comes to hidden hazards) and rivers is not productive in that those signs do save lives--plain and simple. Also, you generalize regarding rivers as if they are all alike. Personal responsibility is about making decisions (good or bad). Information, such as on signs, is used in those decisions.
Delete as you see fit.
I would have to say that I agree and disagree to parts of the blog. First I agree that personal responsibility is or appears to have gone with the wind. It is like the McDonald's Hot Coffee lawsuit. How was it McDonald's fault that a lady set her cup of coffee between her leg and spill it on herself? She ordered "HOT" coffee! Fact is that many people are looking to make a easy buck and if they can sue for it, so be it.
Where I disagree is the signs at the Kern seem to be needed to warn those dumb enough to think a inflected inner tube is a good raft to go down rapids to second guess themselves. Great. To me that sign is nothing more than a road sign warning about curvy road ahead or merging traffic. It is to save lives.
This issue opens up a whole can of worms with our society. Excessive litigation, excessive jury awards, the lack of personal responsibility and accountability, the pointing of fingers. Many times companies and corporations will settle simply to avoid the cost of litigation. What these people don't understand is that whomever they sue is just going to pass on the cost of litigation to the consumer. So when someone sues an auto maker because their loved one was killed in a car crash while driving drunk or speeding or whatever, the rest of us end up footing the bill. The litigant may think they are making the corporation pay, but in reality WE ALL pay! I would like to ask a litigant in that position, "What did getting a settlement from a business that had no fault in an accident really accomplish, other than making you rich?!"
Those selfish people who think they are "getting back" at big business are basically screwing society as a whole! Thanks so much!
Wow, this sure got me lit up! OK, I'm done now...